i had to draw the tin roof with light straining through to
fully appreciate what Abani was saying with that image. the death of his
language is slow and quiet, “slight” and “pursed.” i thought of single words in
his language filtered through the holes in the tin roof—an expansive
privileging of euro-and-ethno-centric culture, language, art, history. i
imagined these single words fragmented, fighting through small spaces in the
dense roof. the lines of the poem are just as important as what exists in the space
between them: silence, space.
i’ve never read a poem like “Dearest Jane” before (in terms
of theme and subject matter). how important to document a female-bodied
soldier’s experience of war, especially the Civil War, one where our US
American memory is mostly (cis)male-centric, aside from tired southern belle and
mammy stereotypes. also, given how many actual female-bodied people participate
as men in war, the chronicling of this perspective is critical (and has been overwhelmingly hidden). this persona poem is so effective and believable because of its
means of delivery (letter) and also because it’s not written with complete
dedication to the reader of the poem, but rather to whom the letter is
addressed. it’s not about what the reader wants or needs to know: there are
things left unsaid by Henrietta to Jane that the reader would probably like to
know (less of the mundane details, more specifics about the war, why this
person is presenting as male, etc). these things go left unsaid, though,
because Jane already knows. often persona poems break the voice by attending
too carefully to the reader. the poem is also not overly “poetic”—it’s casual
in language and tends to the character, though the poetic is there (embedded rhyme, line breaks, etc).
poetry is situated, has a context—historical, temporal,
political, cultural, linguistic, etc. it reflects experiences, time periods,
and histories. it doesn’t exist in a vacuum. it does compile history, even if
it’s not as apparent as Abani’s poems or Harper’s “Advice to Clinton.” poems
like this one point us to histories we leave out, ones that have been misrepresented or under-represented (as
with the Elaine race riots and trials). also, "Faulkner's Centennial 9 25
97"--how interesting for a poem to have that title and to conjure Mammy
Callie--who exists in the background of Faulkner's version of the South, and is
no less important, but is unknown.
I was drawn to Harper's language play in "Natal
Visit" pointing to what comes into common language and how such loaded,
potentially meaningful words and phrases like "land's end" and
"discover" become branded and capitalized upon.
um, okay, Aimee Nezhukumatathil! i was blown away by how i could
feel, see, touch, taste her poems. the rice rolled into a ball catching bones
in the throat, the eggs in their blue cup, the cherries making a gun of the
mouth. also, the language is so rich and full, but the tone and delivery are
casual and understated. ghazals are so complicated and intricate, hard to pull
off, and hers reads seamlessly.
she plays with cliches and tropes about love and sex--red,
cherries, fruit--we've all seen these figures conjured in love poems, poems
about the body and pleasure. she uses these in a new way, and smartly. also, it’s
not a poem that exalts love and sex. it’s regretful. her writing is visceral
and sensory, detailed. “mouth stories” maps out the geography of the tongue and
gives each area of taste in the mouth its own story. again, breathing life into
the sensory, oral experience of love, sex, loss.
“AN ELLIPSIS OF ANTS ON THE WALL” !!!
i want to leave my comments about Maria de los Santos for
class.
-rex
I don't know how I missed the metaphorical value of that tin roof with holes. It's a pretty powerful image, especially when thinking that the tin is the colonizer's encroaching language, and those holes are all the words the speaker has from his own language, his own cultural position. Good idea to draw that out.
ReplyDelete"it does compile history, even if it’s not as apparent as Abani’s poems or Harper’s “Advice to Clinton.” poems like this one point us to histories we leave out, ones that have been misrepresented or under-represented"
ReplyDeleteyes, rex. thank you for articulating this. when I read poetry like this I get this kind of tingling sensation, as if something i being uncovered. I think it comes directly from this sense that histories that are have been left out, that those who could have told the histories have been silenced, and that the poetic work digs out those voices and histories, even if it is through making up some of what might have been there. it reminds me of an article I read by a historian who advocated making up stories in history, or complining stories, so as to fit into "the body shaped holes." this feels very much like what Abani and others are doing, don't you think?
thanks for your thoughts!
YESSSSSSSSS on Aimee!! My jaw dropped at "Fishbone" and "Mouth Stories", specifically. FIshbone echoed for me the very southern customs/urban legends that my great-grandmother passed onto my grandmother, and subsequently, my mother.
ReplyDeleteIf you chew paper, worms get in you.
Put a cross on your leg to stop it from being prickly when it falls asleep.
...and so on.
The ability to save your children from discomfort and be their protectors, whether or not it's seen as valid elsewhere, are the very things that shaped our identity and made us adaptable to, well, life.
The stream of consciousness of her mother switching to Madonna's pregnancy is so telling of the daily musings occupying their brains, somewhere in between fixing dinner, keeping the lights on, and surviving. Aimee, much like myself, fixates on the presence of our mothers (and their creations, like cooking) in the moments I'm sure they're not even aware of.
"ponder the basket of fried smelt
on the table, lined with paper towels to catch
the grease--want to study their eyes
like flat soda..."
Whoa.
This idea of "normality" also, contrasting her breakfast with Sara's "Cheerios, or sometimes if her mother is home: buttered toast and soft boiled eggs...safe, pretty, nothing with eyes."
But, this implies that Aimee's mother is home, always. This is key. So then, what is more normal really? Cheerios, or fried smelt, rolling rice into a ball, and conversations of Madonna?
Her visual imagery is tight and compact. I could visualize the dimes in her bag as she went away to college, toiling again with "normalcy" in an environment with trust fund babies. (I myself went to Hampshire on a 13 hour Greyhound trip from Baltimore, and two GINORMOUS 2-for-1 laundry bags full of all my clothes. I empathize greatly.)
So much more to say, but I'll stop there and say a quick piece about "Mouth Stories". I typically cannot stand erotic poetry, or poetry labelled "erotic". This poem is as erotic as it gets. I melted. Dividing her one night stand memory into the four elements of taste sent my mind to great lengths of the possibilities of form, and going beyond the norms set for poets. This reminded me that there really are no norms...we create them ourselves.
"...The ink
of yesterday's paper, cover
from the rain, drools down my cheek."
I...think I'm truly gonna stop there. It's hot in here.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteslash i wanted to highlight this from you:
ReplyDelete"she plays with cliches and tropes about love and sex--red, cherries, fruit--we've all seen these figures conjured in love poems, poems about the body and pleasure. she uses these in a new way, and smartly. also, it’s not a poem that exalts love and sex. it’s regretful." PREACH.
Yall are excited b/c Rex gravitated toward the hearts of the poem and took us into the imagery. It's so exciting to see the connection--i said that already!
ReplyDeleteAnyway, thanks rex you pulled out the camera and showed us the film
e